Plug and Play: Your Beginner-Friendly Guide to Butt Plugs

Small and simple. Yet surprisingly popular. Here’s why you’d want to give these little helpers a shot.

Tiny Toy, Big Reputation.

Sex toys. They make us curious, right? Sometimes, the humblest, most unassuming of them take us in for a surprise. The butt plug is a great example. Why does it stir up something in the sexual corners of our minds?

Maybe it’s the name. Or its mysterious shape. Maybe the opinions we hear about it. You can’t really get a lukewarm, middleground kind of opinion from folks. They either describe it as something magical or the opposite. Terrifying.

But here’s one true thing. Butt plugs are surprisingly among the most beginner-friendly toys you can find out there. Pretty versatile and enjoyable too. When used correctly of course. You don’t need to be a sex wizard overnight to enjoy them.

You might be completely new to anal play. Simply wondering what the polarizing hype is about. Here, we’ll find out what butt plugs are. How they work and some tips too. Without escalating your experience into a chaotic one.

So let’s talk about the little sex toy. A toy with a big reputation and personality.

What is a Butt Plug?

A butt plug is a sex toy designed for anal play enjoyers out there. And if you’re one of ‘em, it’s a great tool. Inserted comfortably into the anus. Staying in place for a decent period of time.

Unlike humongous dildos (designed for thrusting and movement), butt plugs are about stimulating you with pressure and sensual fullness. Your standard butt plug usually have three main parts:

• Tapered tip for easier insertion
• Wider mid-section to give you that feeling of fullness
• Narrow neck with flared base (for safety)

The last part? Very important. You want it slipping too far inside the anus. A properly flared base helps in preventing that. Your butt is pretty skilled when it comes to plenty of things. But c’mon. That orifice holding on to a small slippery object? Not always its best trait.

So yeah. That flared base’s importance is usually understated. Butt plugs do come in different shapes, sizes and materials. Some are tiny so beginners can enjoy them. Some vibrate. Some are curved for extra pleasure.

Others look shockingly elegant. Like modern art pieces in your gallery. Or maybe sci-fi inspired tools. Even in sex-related innovation, the level of human creativity is just… amazing!

A Short History of Butt Plugs

Believe it or not, anal stimulation’s been a thing for yeah… centuries. Our ancestors were just as curious about pleasure. And as expected, they found ways to enjoy sex in different, creative ways. 

Early versions of anal toys appeared throughout history. But often discussed in the quiet corners. Even labelled as medical devices. By the late 1800s and early 1900s, doctors bizarrely marketed butt plugs as treatments (rectal dilators).

Claiming that they can cure headaches, insanity, constipation and uhm, even acne. Imagine going to your doctor for some stress relief. Leaving their clinic with basically a butt plug in you. History’s pretty strange huh?

Modern butt plugs became more openly available to us in the 60s and 70s. During the sexual revolution that also led to the sexual wellness movement. Butt plugs were promoted more appropriately. As pleasure tools.

Since then, sex-positive talks and improved toy designs have made these toys safer and more comfortable. Less intimidating for newbies out there. Today butt plugs are more accessible to couples, solo explorers, beginners and anal veterans alike.

In other words, you’re not alone in being curious about these playful plugs.

Why Do People Like Butt Plugs?

Not everyone’s a fan of anal play. But to the enjoyers, the short answer is nerves. Lots of them. Your anal area contains a huge number of sensitive nerve endings. Meaning, stimulation feels different but still pleasurable there.

Some folks enjoy the feeling of fullness. Others love the added pressure during sex or masturbation. Adding a layer of anticipation and teasing. The thrill of trying new stuff is quite a thing. Titillating indeed.

Many couples build excitement and add novelty by using butt plugs. Without overcomplicating the sweet and sexy parts. Increasing anticipation with a naughty twist. There’s also that delicious, psychological side.

By trying something fresh, you can build trust and communication. Closeness as well. Butt plugs can be your tools in discussing boundaries and comfort levels. Strengthening your bond and confidence.

One more thing, it’s pretty humbling to read an instruction booklet. For something you’d be inserting in your butt. A lil hilarious too. Without losing your naughty energy.

Related: Anal Orgasms Explained: A Safe and Simple Guide for Newbies

How to Use a Butt Plug? Properly. Safely.

This part is important. Using your butt plug is not complicated. But it asks for your patience, communication (if you’re exploring with a partner) and lubrication. Lots and lots of it.

1. Start with the right size

If you’re a beginner, pick a smaller one. Specifically designed for newcomers. Tiny is good, wise and friendly. Starting too large is your fastest way to turn your curiosity into regret. 

Don’t let your anal adventure turn into a nightmare. Look for the silicone type. With a tapered tip and flexible material. Again, don’t rush into a bigger plug right away.

2. Relax

This is not a race alright. Take your time with foreplay. Kissing, touching, deep breathing. Or anything else that helps your body relax. Naturally. Because tension will make insertion uncomfortable.

Relaxation on the other hand, makes everything easier and enjoyable for you. A warm shower before your anal play can also help. Clean and relaxed. Nice! Sexy combo.

3. Use plenty of lube

Your butthole is not as moist/lubricated as the other orifices. So the almighty lube is essential. Apply it generously. As in generously. Without missing a spot. Apply it to both your toy and body.

Because sadly, optimism alone won’t make your anus self-lubricate. Go for the water-based ones. Safe and very beginner-friendly. Very compatible with most silicone sex toys.

4. Insert slowly

Gently tease your anal area before you slowly put the butt plug in. Go gradually. Pause whenever you need it. Don’t rush or push with force. This is not some endurance test.

Breathing slowly and deeply will help you here. 

If something feels painful instead of unfamiliar, stop. Immediately. Anal play should not feel sharp, forced or painful. Please don’t finish your anal play with unnecessary tears or scrapes. Your comfort comes first. Always.

5. Let your body adjust

Once your butt plug’s inserted, stay still for at least a moment. Allow your rectal muscles to relax naturally around it. Some beginners make this mistake: Trying to move immediately before their body gets the chance to adjust. Give it time. Your butt plug’s not running away.

6. Explore different sensations

You can enjoy other sexual activities while wearing your butt plug. You can kiss your partner, perform oral sex or have penetrative sex. Masturbate while your butt plug is in if you’re playing solo.

There’s no universal best method. Your goal here is to find what works and feels good for you (and your partner).

7. Remove slowly

Once you’re done, feeling satisfied with your session, gently remove the plug out of your anus. Before pulling it out, relax your muscles. The same relaxed state before you insert the toy. Use more lube if needed. Don’t rush it, comprende?

You’re probably looking for quick butt plug advice. Wanting to hear an expert’s voice. Check out Dr. Werner’s friendly reminder.

Some Advice About Butt Plugs 

Common Butt Plug Mistakes to Avoid

Going too big too fast

Your curiosity is absolutely wonderful. When it comes to butt plugs though, please don’t let overconfidence take control. Starting small is a wiser decision. As it allows you to get comfortable first. Building your butt plug confidence gradually.

Skipping lubricant

Lube, lube, plenty of lube. This may sound like a broken record. But using lubrication is crucial especially when you’re inserting stuff inside you (including anal play). Some people still ignore this part for some reason. Finding out later that lubricants are super important.

Forgetting the flared base

Don’t use toys with no flared base for anal play. Ever. Because oof. Emergency room doctors have seen their fair share of accidents already. Don’t be that patient though. If you don’t want to end up in a not so sexy or even dangerous situation. Flared base, got it? Roger that.

Treating it like a performance

Your relaxation matters more than you know, looking like an expert. You don’t need to fake your confidence. In a delicate setting like this. You need to communicate (if you’re having anal fun with a partner). Patience and comfort too. Some awkward giggles are part of the fun anyway.

What to Look for When You’re Buying a Butt Plug?

The magical worlds of sex toys. Oddly overwhelming at times. Suddenly you’re comparing items like you compare kitchen tools or something. But here are butt plug things you must consider.

Body-safe material

Premium, body-safe silicone is your best bet when it comes to picking your butt plug. Why? Because it’s soft, flexible and non-porous. More importantly, butt plugs made of this type of silicone are beginner-friendly.

Avoid cheap, mysterious, questionable materials. Don’t even try to improvise here. Your safety. That takes the top spot in your list o sex toy priorities.

A flared base

Cannot stress this enough when it comes to your intimate anal play. Butt plug with a flared base. Seriously non-negotiable. Another part that takes care of safety and convenience. Making handling easier.

Beginner-friendly size

A slim and tapered plug is ideal. Smaller toys help your body adjust without force or rushing. Making your progress gradual and comfortable. Ignore the ego that shouts “big, big, big!” for now. Your lovely butt will appreciate it.

Smooth design

Seamless, smooth plugs are easier to clean. More comfortable to insert as well. You can also get a butt plugs with a subtle texture or curve. As long as it doesn’t give your butt any sharp or rough feelings. You don’t want unnecessary friction joining in.

Vibrating options

Some people enjoy the very stripped-down, straightforward version of a butt plug. But you can also get extra pleasure/stimulation from vibrating ones. Adding a twist of teasing. Are you looking for fun butt plugs? 

Here’s the good news…You can get them here! If you want more playthings to join your intimate, steamy anal sessions, look at this lovely collection of anal toys.

Related: How to Make Vulva Owners Say Yes to First-Time Anal

Butt Plug Cleaning and Storage Tips

Cleaning your butt plug properly. That’s not optional. You can treat cleanliness as an important part of  responsible sex toy ownership. Fortunately, it’s sooo easy. Before and after use, wash it with mild soap and water.

You can also use toy cleaners. Formulated to keep your butt plugs/vibrators in top shape. Keeping you safe in the process too. Pay extra attention to those tiny, textured areas. The grooves. 

Dry your plug completely before storing. Trapped moisture? Yikes! That leads to bacterial/fungal growth. Uncool. Quite unsexy. So make sure your toys and containers are completely dry. Store them separately too. 

Jamming ‘em together into a single drawer box: Not ideal. Can’t treat them like old phone chargers with tangled cables. Inspect your items regularly. Look for cracks, tears or any signs of damage or malfunction. 

When your favorite ones start looking worn out (from overuse or exposure), replace them. Even if you get emotionally attached - like seeing it with sentimentality, don’t put your health at risk. Maybe you can keep your favorite ones in a box somewhere. 

But if they’re damaged, please retire them from use.

Can Beginners Actually Enjoy Butt Plugs?

Absolutely. Given that you’re a big fan of anal stimulation. Or you see it as a wonderful side piece while you’re doing other naughty acts. You can treat butt plugs as the main star. Sometimes, your supportive tool.

One of the biggest myths around butt plugs is this: You need to be ultra experienced or a wild, wild spirit to have fun with it. Not the case at all. Some of butt plugs’ biggest supporters started with just curiosity and some nervousness.

The difference between a good and bad butt plug experience comes down to a few things. Pacing, communication and expectations. Realistic ones. Slow, relaxed, safe approach? Very sexy.

So if you’re thinking about using one, don’t try to speedrun it. You’re not competing for a world record. You’re trying to have an organic good time with these anal helpers. Let the chapters unfold gently. Gradual progress is part of the hot fun.

Special Thanks:

Dr. Michael A. Werner, MD - Urologist - Maze Men’s Health

James Felton - IFL Science

Adrienne Santos-Longhurst - Healthline

Looking for ways to master backdoor pleasure? Here are your guides to 5 Best Anal Sex Positions, How to Make Vulva Owners Say Yes to First-Time Anal and Anal Orgasms Explained: A Safe and Simple Guide for Newbies.

You might also like:

Backstage Pass: The Top Five Sex Positions From Behind

Prostate Massagers

Ass Worship: It’s Not Just a Kink. It’s Attention and Chemistry.